Staking Amount Required Per Magnitude for Proof-Of-Distributed-Computing Mining

Started by Rob Andrews, March 09, 2018, 12:19:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

What UTXO Staking Method and Required Amount should we use for PODC Mining?

NONE (0), We should Remove the requirement
0 (0%)
LEGACY - Lets Put it back to the 0-50,000 UTXO Chart where 50,001 BBP = 100% UTXO
2 (3.9%)
250 BBP Per Magnitude Required to be at 100% UTXO
0 (0%)
500 BBP Per Magnitude Required to be at 100% UTXO
0 (0%)
1000 BBP Per Magnitude Required to be at 100% UTXO
0 (0%)
2500 BBP Per Magnitude Required to be at 100% UTXO
1 (2%)
5000 BBP Per Magnitude Required to be at 100% UTXO
0 (0%)
10,000 BBP Per Magnitude Required to be at 100% UTXO
16 (31.4%)
20,000 BBP Per Magnitude Required to be at 100% UTXO
2 (3.9%)
50,000 BBP Per Magnitude Required to be at 100% UTXO
5 (9.8%)
5 BBP Per RAC Required for 100% UTXO
0 (0%)
10 BBP Per RAC Required for 100% UTXO
3 (5.9%)
20 BBP Per RAC Required for 100% UTXO
19 (37.3%)
30 BBP Per RAC Required for 100% UTXO
0 (0%)
50 BBP Per RAC Required for 100% UTXO
1 (2%)
75 BBP Per RAC Required for 100% UTXO
0 (0%)
100 BBP Per RAC Required for 100% UTXO
1 (2%)
250 BBP Per RAC Required for 100% UTXO
1 (2%)
500 BBP Per RAC Required for 100% UTXO
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 51

Voting closed: April 01, 2018, 09:01:08 AM

znffal

Ok so I changed my vote to 50,000 per Magnitude.

Reason is this: When rewards drop to around 1.3 million BBP total, 1mag = 1(/1000)*1.3 million = 1300 BBP.
This means that it will take ~39 days to pay back your stake which I think is reasonable.

In fact, it is bad for myself personally because it is a lot of stake, but I think it is best for the coin overall.


EDIT: For comparison:

BBP/magnitude      days to pay back stake

250                               0.2 days
500                               0.38 days
1000                             0.77 days
2500                             1.92 days
5000                              3.85 days
10000                            7.7 days
20000                             15.4 days
50000                             38.5 days

aikida3k

50000 still becomes a static 50 million lockup.  For comparison we have 169 masternodes which gives a lockup of nearly 262 million.  Right now total supply is 459 million.  So that lockup of 262 million increased price from a consistent 10-20 satoshi to a consistent 25-35 satoshi with some higher peaks.  I like staking to RAC because it will sop up supply, and it should still be affordable if bitcoin takes off whereas masternodes will become unaffordable while we still have a lot of supply to come.  I can imagine a scenario where the annual returns are attractive on masternodes, but the price because of bitcoin makes them expensive and out of reach for most people, but they could still afford to either buy and hold, or buy, stake and crunch. 

aikida3k

Staking per MAG keeps the race to the bottom in.  Right now a rational player will introduce as many computers to crunch as capital will allow because breakevens are so high.  Therefore introduce as many computers as capital allows until your breakeven is reached.  Sell your biblepay on the market.  In the process biblepay has no natural buyers, only natural sellers- the miners and the crunchers.  Buyers, not miners are the ones who are really supporting the orphans.  Miners and crunchers introduce supply while buyers sop up supply.  It works the same way in all commodities:  If the price of oil is above your expected breakeven, you go out and explore for more oil until you reach your breakevens.  In the process you introduce more supply on the market which eventually makes prices come down again.  If you are a cattle rancher and prices are above your breakeven, you increase your herd size and your production until you reach your breakevens.  Selling your calves on the market with greater supply eventually brings prices back down.  The difference between BBP and oil and cattle?  There are natural buyers:  people have to buy oil to make gasoline and diesel.  People have to buy fat cattle to make beef.  People don't have to keep buying BBP once the static stake amount to magnitude is reached, however, staking to RAC, miners then become natural buyers as they seek to increase the amount of BBP they can generate.  Traders and investors see this and are encouraged and buy. 

We don't do enough to encourage buyers.  Staking to RAC would help that.

MIP

I'm also for the staking-per-RAC idea.

It allows decoupling users from what other team members are doing (as it would happen with a relative number as magnitude). It can also boost the coin price and incentives to keep it instead selling it.

You add more CPU power = you must stake more BBP. 

We can even afford to change the number of BBP per RAC unit in the future as we see the evolution of this new PoDC system (for example if the overall RAC of the team surpasses the amount of BBP in circulation).


T-Mike

Quote from: 616westwarmoth on March 12, 2018, 12:52:06 PM
I commented in the other poll, but here is a short version of why staking per RAC is, to me, not workable.

Right now, if you stake per RAC at 10BBP/RAC, a 10K RAC machine would make roughly 15K BBP/day, and need a stake of 100K.  So 8 days to stake equity, much to fast in my thoughts.  But by the end of the year I expect us to be at 20M RAC and the reward will have dropped by about 12%, so the same 10K machine would make about 700BBP/day, or 150 days to stake equity.

Any system that doesn't slide based on the reward (which then becomes hard to understand) will be too generous to us now or too restrictive to us later.

The most fair system would be very hard to explain to new users, but would be some multiple of your daily reward held as stake, 100x or 150x spring to mind.  But coding that and presenting that in a way that could be easily to predict would likely be too complex for many new users.

I would argue that the most fair system is to not enforce staking at all.

MIP

My humble opinion:

Even though we know that helping orphans/distressed people is a comforting feeling, we must also watch for the investor interest.

Remember, no investors (mining, MN, traders...) = no coin = no help for the needy

The average investor is our friend, not our enemy. We don't have to scare or fear them, we need to manage them so there is no room for unnecessary greed, but for healthy returns.

To distribute wealth, first we need to create it. So I agree with some of T-Mike points.

Rob Andrews

Quote from: MIP on March 14, 2018, 06:54:19 AM
My humble opinion:

Even though we know that helping orphans/distressed people is a comforting feeling, we must also watch for the investor interest.

Remember, no investors (mining, MN, traders...) = no coin = no help for the needy

The average investor is our friend, not our enemy. We don't have to scare or fear them, we need to manage them so there is no room for unnecessary greed, but for healthy returns.

To distribute wealth, first we need to create it. So I agree with some of T-Mike points.

I really dont understand your perspective here MIP, I think my opinion is completely aligned with the investor.

Im Not here for the Miner, Im here for the small unbanked home PC driven average joe six pack and the investor.

Not sure how you can come to the conclusion Im here for the 1% or the botnet LOL :)

Sorry if I came across harshly Mike-T, I guess I made the assumption that you were biased because you own 20% of the magnitude.

Lets call a truce and start over with a clean slate.


T-Mike

Quote from: Rob A. on March 14, 2018, 10:24:31 AM
I really dont understand your perspective here MIP, I think my opinion is completely aligned with the investor.

Im Not here for the Miner, Im here for the small unbanked home PC driven average joe six pack and the investor.

Not sure how you can come to the conclusion Im here for the 1% or the botnet LOL :)

Sorry if I came across harshly Mike-T, I guess I made the assumption that you were biased because you own 20% of the magnitude.

Lets call a truce and start over with a clean slate.

Agreed Rob, thank you for the apology.

MIP

Quote from: Rob A. on March 14, 2018, 10:24:31 AM
Not sure how you can come to the conclusion Im here for the 1% or the botnet LOL :)

I was not targeting you in my comments, it was just an open thought.

jaapgvk

I'm still really trying to wrap my head around the economics behind the Mag/RAC proposal. But would it maybe be an idea to have a Stake per MAG version with inflation (relative to the deflation of BBP or something)?

So the amount of total BBP that needs to be staked per MAG would inflate with for example 1.8% per month.

jaapgvk

Still haven't voted. Both sides have their merits. Does anyone have any last-minute thoughts?

fahq420

It doesnt allow me to vote, i understand you want real users, not botnets.

but IMO forcing people to stake the coin to get rewarded for mining the coin... is a HUGE mistake. Also, this huge convoluted process of boinc with the 2 projects and stuff... is potentially going to keep the range of users this coin gets used by, extremely small.   I've been mining for Several years, way before mt gox, and bitmain were even around. Not trying to say that i know more than any one, but i have been listening to "normal every day miners" for quite some time, and I think the way this is going with all the complications, is not going to do well for the coin in general, but i pray that you find a way to make it work... The Lord (and his word, and so forth) needs to available to all.

jaapgvk

Quote from: fahq420 on April 01, 2018, 01:51:26 AM
It doesnt allow me to vote, i understand you want real users, not botnets.

but IMO forcing people to stake the coin to get rewarded for mining the coin... is a HUGE mistake. Also, this huge convoluted process of boinc with the 2 projects and stuff... is potentially going to keep the range of users this coin gets used by, extremely small.   I've been mining for Several years, way before mt gox, and bitmain were even around. Not trying to say that i know more than any one, but i have been listening to "normal every day miners" for quite some time, and I think the way this is going with all the complications, is not going to do well for the coin in general, but i pray that you find a way to make it work... The Lord (and his word, and so forth) needs to available to all.

The poll is closed.

Could you maybe read this guide and give feedback if possible on how to make the process easier? https://www.biblepay-central.org/en/mining-how-to/

The staking bit should just say that the wallet sets the staking-amount automatically (or stake everything you have if you have less than what is calculated by the wallet).

sunk818

Can you make Magnitude 0 to 100 instead of 1,000? 0 to 100 makes more sense as a percentage than 0 to 1000. Easier to comprehend right away.
BH6oxjLkyz3z8FYpvU3ZR7PTZ31Xt9DkXZ

jaapgvk

Quote from: LifeThruGrace on May 11, 2018, 01:43:49 PM
Can you make Magnitude 0 to 100 instead of 1,000? 0 to 100 makes more sense as a percentage than 0 to 1000. Easier to comprehend right away.

I agree with this. It's more intuitive.